filter problem

[jpeteet]

Ok I wiped my filters dealing with this and added the following 2:

src: all
dest: all
type: vnc_1
protocol: tcp
src port: 9040
dst port: all
no ack, no stateful

src: all
dest: all
type: vnc_2
protocol: tcp
src port: all
dst port: 9040
no ack, no stateful

Here is the situation as it sits. I can get from my desktop to the offsite. I cannot get from the offsite to my desktop. On the incoming there is a different thing going on. I have a public IP natted to my desktop address. It has worked well in the past until I started locking down access. Once I found the original problem of a filter allowing all IP inbound this stopped working. If I unload the firewall communication works both ways. Any suggestions would be great as I am at a loss right now. I will keep working on it and let you know if I find anything out.