I have FTP server running on internal NW 6.5 SP4
Works as good as expected

There is static NAT of this servers private IP to public IP with BM 3.7 SP3

I have users complain that using Dreamweaver up publish the site (connecting
to this FTP from outside of firewall)
does not work

All sorts of timeouts etc happen

As it works internally then the only reason is NAT

I have all the required (I hope) rules in place:

Or am I missing something for it to work correctly?

Seb

EXCLUDE ENABLED NOLOG, INTRFACE:<Any> IP:10.0.0.4, IP:pid=TCP port=<All>
srcport=20, INTRFACE:PUBLIC, FTP data request to FTP internal server
EXCLUDE ENABLED NOLOG, INTRFACE:<Any> IP:10.0.0.4, IP:pid=TCP port=<All>
srcport=21, INTRFACE:PUBLIC, Allows request to FTP internal server

EXCLUDE ENABLED LOG, INTRFACE:PUBLIC, IP:pid=TCP port=21 srcport=<All>,
INTRFACE:<Any> IP:10.0.0.4, Allows access to FTP
EXCLUDE ENABLED NOLOG, INTRFACE:PUBLIC, IP:pid=TCP port=20
srcport=<All>, INTRFACE:<Any> IP:10.0.0.4, FTP access