This makes sense. Just not sure why phase 1 keeps failing durring publication. It fails for each application, however the identity sources publish just fine. I will open a call, but if we can get an idea of what the different phases are and what happens in each phase, would it help us know where an issue lies with the data or configuration? The messages are very generic.

Would a maintenance help with anything? I'm guessing not as it would only be touching past snapshot type data that isn't currently in use.